Friendships don’t rely on agreement. They rely on trust. Your best friends are the ones you can be completely yourself with, no filter, and miraculously they still want to hang out with you.
Work is no different. Authenticity is what buys trust, and yet most teams have some people playing a very solo game in a co-op space.
Sometimes they’re playing for strict personal advantage. It’s all “we” in the meeting, but somehow the credit drifts their way and the blame drifts somewhere else. “Oh, sorry, did I forget to CC you?” Sometimes they’re playing for cover. A quick glance around the room to see who’s listening, working out which version of themselves is safe today.
You’ve heard the advice to dance like no-one’s watching. These people dance differently depending on who is watching, and they’re busy judging everyone else’s dance too.
At the far end of the scale, the performance stops being a tactic and becomes the only strategy. I once ran a diagnostic where I interviewed the 32 most senior people in a business of about 120. Almost half of them, privately and without prompting, named the same leader as someone they simply couldn’t trust. And that leader had been promoted, more than once.
Where the system rewards being seen to do well, or nodding along to the corporate line, the performers rise. They’re very good at managing up. The damage shows up everywhere else: decisions made on a curated version of the truth, teams that stop raising problems, good people who leave or quietly tune out. (The culture that grows these people is a story for another week.)
But I don’t want to stay there, because these extremes are rare. The far more common version is sitting in most leadership teams right now.
It’s the good leader who’s just looking to play their part. Often, they’re new to the job, carrying a healthy dose of imposter syndrome. Capable, decent, well regarded, and spending a surprising amount of energy pretending to be the leader they already are.
They put on the leader voice. They hold back the honest “I’m not sure.” They agree in the room and then do nothing or disagree later where it feels safer. Not because they’re scheming, but because they’re genuinely unsure, or don’t want to make a fuss, or be the person who points out the problem. Somewhere along the way they decided to edit the real them. “Honestly inauthentic” if you’ll allow me that contradiction in terms.
There’s a good reason for it. We’re tribal apes, and life is a team sport. Our success depends on the group doing well AND on how we’re doing relative to everyone else in it, and the brain keeps a close eye on both. When it feels unsafe to be wrong (even when it isn’t), we tend to say less, commit to nothing, and keep our powder dry and our options open. We get more vigilant about what the mob is thinking, and feel a greater need to fit in.
The cost is that you never quite get the real person. The business never quite gets the benefit of the mind and perspective you’re paying for, you just get a facsimile of the group. This is bad for the person as well, because running two versions of yourself is exhausting, for them and for everyone around them trying to work out what they think.
Are there people in your leadership team spending a little too much time “performing” their role rather than doing it? Do you sense they’re more concerned with managing what you think than with telling you what they think?
How much simpler would our conversations be if we could all just put the act down?
How refreshing would it be to hear a leader say, “It looks like we made an error pricing like that, on the next one we should adjust our strategy.” Or “I don’t really want to manage people. I was much happier in my technical role, which I really was good at.”
We all present different versions of ourselves at different times, you and me included.
Authenticity builds happiness, and happier people are more authentic. They’re secure enough that they don’t need to win at someone else’s expense or hide what they really think. They say what they mean, own their mistakes, and are genuinely pleased when a colleague does well.
There’s real relief in being the same person in the meeting as you are at your desk or at the barbecue. One version of you is a lot less work to run than two, and people trust a leader when they know what they’re getting.
When leaders are happier, everything works better.
Take the quick [Integrated Leaders Diagnostic] for a fast and targeted baseline to build from.


