“We should all agree on a way forward.” (Provided it’s my way forward, and I don’t have to change anything.)
Have you worked with people who are open and generous with their opinions, right up until the spotlight lands on them? Then the ‘closed’ sign goes up.
The arms fold. The jaw sets. The smile stays, but it leaves the eyes. Then some version of “I think you’ll find…” or “We tried that in 2019.” And my personal favourite passive-aggressive opener, “With respect…”, which roughly translates as “You have no idea what you’re talking about.”
Sometimes it’s a long explanation nobody asked for, or a follow-up email with three people cc’d. More often it’s a non-committal “Hmmm, maybe”, and then business as usual carries on as if the conversation never happened.
Closed minds cause more delay, frustration and missed opportunity than pretty much anything else I see. They usually come from one of two places.
The first is status. Where performance is the measure, nobody wants to be seen not nailing it, so a question becomes an attack to defend. The second is clinging to an idea, a belief built up over years and often grounded in hard personal experience. “Our industry’s too unpredictable – forecasts are useless.”
Either way, as we saw last week, a brain busy protecting itself can’t explore at the same time. And when we’re tired, stressed or feeling cornered, the shutters come down faster. I know I get more stubborn. Don’t you?
So what do you do about it?
The first option is to get better at communicating and influencing, which means raising hard issues and giving feedback in ways that don’t set off the defences. It’s valuable, and I run programs in exactly this space. But it puts the whole load on the person asking. It’s also slow going with someone who hears every question as an attack, however carefully you phrase it.
The second is to help people be more open in the first place, secure enough in themselves that a question doesn’t feel like a threat. That’s emotional intelligence, built from the inside. Most senior people can have a grown-up conversation about strategy without it getting personal, some of the time. What if you could shift the average: more open, more of the time?
Ultimately you want both: skilled conversations, with people secure enough to hear them.
Open-minded isn’t soft. The best people you’ve worked with hold a view and argue for it, sometimes doggedly. But give them new information, and if it stacks up, they’ll change their mind. No fuss.
So how open are the people around you? And while you’re there, how open are you?
Happy people are open. They’re secure enough that being wrong doesn’t feel like an attack, so they can afford to listen, ask the better question and change course without losing face. And there’s a lightness to it. Not having to defend every position you’ve ever taken frees up a surprising amount of energy, and makes you a lot better company along the way.
When your leaders are happier, everything works better.
Take the quick [Integrated Leaders Diagnostic] for a fast and targeted baseline to build from.


